Diner becomes Pizzeria

/ Updated on June 24, 2016

The Lewes Diner that replaced Annabella's restaurant on Savannah Road in Lewes is, after being open for about a year, apparently attempting to rebrand itself as the Lewes Pizzeria. Early reports suggest that the menu is the same except, according to Foodie Follower Olivia, they have eliminated the breakfast items (which, if diners' reports and emails to me are to be believed, is no great loss), and have added the pizzas. They're really going to have to step up their game to equal the pizzas at the neighboring Mr. P's or Touch of Italy. We'll check it out and keep you posted.

Add Your Comment
  1. Avatar Bernard says:

    Gave the Lewes Diner a real try on three or four occasions. Sorry to report that it just doesn’t measure up to other diners for Breakfast – Lunch or Dinner. And to boot it is expensive. They really need to get their act together since they have steep competition with Ocean Grille at Five Points and Honeys in town.

  2. Avatar Olivia says:

    They dropped the breakfast menu altogether. Breakfast was their mainstay on weekends. Though the one time we were there for breakfast, I found the eggs benedict tasted like cardboard, and what was supposed to be Hollandaise sauce tasted more like cheese wiz. Perhaps it’s a good thing there’s no more breakfast offerings. The sandwiches and burgers also used to taste like cardboard. Flavorless.
    I haven’t tried the pizzas yet but the prices seem disproportionately high for this area.

    • The Rehoboth Foodie The Rehoboth Foodie says:

      Olivia…thanks for the update! I will modify my post to reflect that. Your impressions of the place reflect the many emails I have received regarding people’s experiences there. Apparently these owners don’t realize how much competition there is around them. Lewes isn’t Oak Orchard.

  3. Avatar Susan Crichley says:

    After Annabelleas it was Lewes Diner with breakfast items and now it will only be another Pizza place??

    • The Rehoboth Foodie The Rehoboth Foodie says:

      Note that the post states that the old menu will still be in effect (for what it’s worth) – only there will be pizza too

Add Your Comment

What would you like to do?