What would you like to do?

Reviews are filtered by OVERALL rating only., which combines food, service and satisfaction. Individual reviews contains more detailed ratings.

Catchers Restaurant & Catering

/ Updated on May 31, 2018

I’ve always thought of Catchers primarily as a catering outfit with a few seats in the front for wayward travelers. And in spite of the many emails I have received over the years suggesting I try it out, I remained … Continue reading

Read Full Review 2

Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls

/ Updated on March 29, 2017

Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls is open at 67 Rehoboth Avenue on the Ocean Block (where Nonna’s Sweet Treats used to be). Mason’s is a household word in Annapolis and the lobster rolls are quite tasty. How do I know? Because … Continue reading

Read Full Review 4

Jake’s Seafood House

/ Updated on December 2, 2017

Earlier this year it was brought to my attention that there has never been a review of Jake’s Seafood House on RehobothFoodie.com. There are about 300 other restaurant articles here, so what was the problem!? I won’t bore you with … Continue reading

Read Full Review 1

Big Fish Grill

/ Updated on June 15, 2017

Big Fish Grill is a good example of a big, well-run Rehoboth Beach dining establishment. This is not to disparage other great local spots, but the number of people they move through there on a busy summer evening, and the consistently positive … Continue reading

Read Full Review 21

Chesapeake & Maine

/ Updated on March 2, 2017

The old Finbar’s is long gone (do you remember Potpourri before that?), and Dogfish Head’s tribute to Eastern Seaboard seafood is going strong. Those of you who frequented Finbar’s will not recognize the place, except for vestiges of the bar … Continue reading

Read Full Review 6

The Crab House

/ Updated on November 30, 2016

Many years ago, there was a restaurant called The Crab House in the building that now houses Big Fish Grill on Coastal Highway. It was much smaller than the present facility. When the Sugrue family took over that property to … Continue reading

Read Full Review 14

Fins Ale House & Raw Bar

/ Updated on June 15, 2017

Fins and Claws restaurants have been fixtures on Rehoboth Avenue for a very long time. In spite of business partnership shakeups and changes in management over the years, Jeff Hamer et al have done a good job maintaining quality and … Continue reading

Read Full Review 5

Hooked Seafood & Martini Bar

/ Updated on May 30, 2014

Rehoboth Beach headlines read, “Martini Tom is Back!” Tom Garvey does indeed reign supreme at his old haunt in Midway Shopping Center. The ghosts of Tutto Bene, Adriatico and Betty’s Pure & Simple have long since given way to Hooked Seafood & … Continue reading

Read Full Review 16

Henlopen City Oyster House

/ Updated on June 8, 2016

Experienced Rehoboth restaurateurs Chris Bisaha and Joe Baker have created Henlopen City Oyster House with a bright, friendly atmosphere. They say that 75% of their ingredients are procured from local farmers and purveyors. (I’ve been asked not to elaborate on their … Continue reading

Read Full Review 22

Claws Seafood House

/ Updated on June 15, 2017

Claws is an upbeat, noisy restaurant. Of course, it is a beachy crab house with a busy bar and people hammering on innocent crustaceans, drinking beer and having fun. In a previous incarnation of this review, I complained about some terrible service we received … Continue reading

Read Full Review 7