The Rehoboth Foodie is pleased to report that on May 1, 2019, Lewes’ iconic Buttery restaurant morphed into 2ND STREET TAVERN. Out with the old, in with the new.
Owner Wilson Gates and family were never truly able to maintain the original fine-dining icon created by John Donato and Twain Gonzales. So after a major plumbing issue this winter, they chose to redefine their target audience. This was a very wise decision. The new 2nd Street Tavern offers a large selection of draft beers, an inviting, open area with couches and chairs for relaxing, and a more wallet-friendly menu.
Wilson’s new menu, created in collaboration with Chef Shane Kellagher, has an upbeat tavern vibe but still celebrates the old Trader Mansion at 2nd & Savannah. The bar centers around a 12-tap draft system focused on local crafts. The new “inside-out” bar utilizes as much of the old bar as possible to pay homage to the historical integrity of the building. I believe the inside-out bar will be the star of the show. Check it out!
Local chef Shane Kellagher is the kitchen boss. Kellagher was the opening chef at 14 Global in Bethany Beach, and after several short stints elsewhere, settled down for a while as the opening chef for the new owners of Shorebreak Lodge. If my intuition is working properly, I believe Shane has finally found a home.
2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek1/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek2/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek3/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek4/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek5/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek6/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek7/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek8/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek9/10 2nd St. Tavern: Sneak Peek10/10
The pub menu offered at the media/friends & family reception sported (among other things) a delicious mushroom ravioli, a very good pimiento beer cheese dip with perfectly crispy crostini, amazingly tender braised short ribs (accompanied by perfectly done broccoli) and pork belly bao buns. Three salads with an exceptionally delicious dressing were also part of the opening carte.
A larger menu is on the horizon. I was sworn to secrecy, but a large selection of salads, burgers and pub-friendly dishes will be front and center. Not to mention Gretchen Gates’ famous, often-imitated-yet-never-duplicated hummus! We will return and post more photos. Scroll through the pics and see some of the inside decor!
2nd Street Tavern is in the old Trader mansion at the corner of Savannah Road and 2nd Street, directly across from Touch of Italy. The restaurant completes a trio of eateries on Savannah consisting of 2nd Street Tavern, Vinay Hosmane and GG Gupta’s Raas restaurant, and Meghan Lee’s Heirloom. I believe this group of restaurants will change the face of dining in Lewes. Call (302) 645-7755 for reservations.
Photos of the restaurant interior are courtesy of The Buzzlette, in all her moistness.